MY KOLKATA EDUGRAPH
ADVERTISEMENT
Regular-article-logo Wednesday, 11 February 2026

Word from Milan: Din on thin is boring

Read more below

SOPHIE HARDACH Published 30.09.06, 12:00 AM
A model at Milan Fashion Week. (Reuters)

Milan, Sept. 29 (Reuters): “If that’s all your article is going to be about, you’d better talk to someone else.”

Standing in the backstage area of a Burberry fashion show, Christopher Bailey, usually the most charming and polite designer one could hope to interview, just snapped.

I had started by asking him about his view on Spain’s decision to ban underweight models from Madrid fashion week. He replied calmly: “We have to use common sense.”

So I asked what common sense meant in practice. Had Burberry ever turned away underweight models? Had Bailey ever seen a model and thought “she looks too thin”?

This was when he broke off the interview, ending with the fashion world’s ultimate put-down: “It’s just boring.”

His comment sums up the fashion pack’s reaction to a raging debate over models that look sick and underfed.

It’s boring.

To be fair, Bailey’s annoyance was understandable. He wanted to celebrate his show of cool mini-dresses and elegant coats, the result of months of hard work, not discuss eating disorders.

And yet, the twig-like arms protruding from the pretty bell-sleeves at Burberry; the waists cinched to cartoon-like proportions at Dolce & Gabbana’s D&G show; the sunken cheeks and bony shoulders at Prada; all begged some questions.

The answers came mostly in the form of shoulder-shrugging, eye-rolling, and stifled yawns.

“I think it’s discrimination (to ban underweight models). We are skinny, this is our work. There are lots of overweight people working in offices but I’m not going to say ‘This girl is fat, she can’t work in an office’,” said Valentina Zelyaeva, a 23-year-old Russian.

But Zelyaeva, a willowy blonde, also pointed out many girls at the shows were 14-year-olds who were skinny because they had not reached puberty.

So designers dress up 14-year-olds to make them look like 19-year-olds who look great in clothes that will be sold to 40-year-olds.

It would be simplistic to say that this child-woman beauty ideal is the main factor behind eating disorders.

Yet it also seems cowardly to deny any connection. When I was a teenager, two of my close friends developed anorexia. For both, it started with a diet to “look better”. They insisted they were eating normally, even as their arms started to look like stick drawings.

When 24-year-old Shannan Click from New York, sitting with a plate of grilled vegetables and lettuce on her lap, told me she and her fellow models were naturally thin, I was reminded of those friends.

“If I want a hamburger, I’ll have a hamburger. My whole family is thin and we all eat like crazy,” she said.

Click, with a body mass index of about 17.2, would have been barred from Madrid fashion week, which set the cut-off at 18. Yet to me, she did not look sickly thin. She looked beautifully thin.

Maybe, after seeing row upon row of tall, bony teenagers on the catwalks and backstage, I had simply become unable to distinguish between the two.

Follow us on:
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT