Home / India / Drill in Valley: Call reporters and beat them

Drill in Valley: Call reporters and beat them

The journalists blamed the government for failing to provide an enabling environment to operate freely
A trooper stands guard in Srinagar on Sunday
A trooper stands guard in Srinagar on Sunday
(PTI photo)

Muzaffar Raina   |   Srinagar   |   Published 10.02.20, 09:43 PM

Journalists in Kashmir have broken their silence on alleged police excesses, listing specific instances of assaults, threats and intimidation to reveal their sources during the six-month lockdown linked to the revocation of the special status of Jammu and Kashmir.

None of the journalists revealed their sources. Source protection or source confidentiality is one of the pillars of independent journalism that journalists have zealously guarded in parts of the world, risking imprisonment and worse. Source protection is based on a recognition that without a credible guarantee of anonymity, many would be deterred from sharing information of public interest with journalists.


The Kashmir Press Club convened a formal meeting on Monday to express concern. All journalist associations in the Valley joined the meeting.

The journalists blamed the government for failing to provide an enabling environment to operate freely.

The immediate trigger for the meeting was the recent questioning by police of two journalists for carrying a statement of the Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front (JKLF).

Senior journalist Naseer Ganai, who works with Outlook magazine, and journalist Haroon Nabi were summoned to the counter-insurgency centre on February 8, where they were questioned for reporting a JKLF statement.

“I was asked to reveal the email ID from which I had got the statement,” a Press Club statement quoted Ganai as saying.

At a meeting with journalists later, Valley police chief Vijay Kumar had defended the decision to question the journalists, saying the JKLF was a banned organisation and its call for a shutdown amounted to instigating the people.

A spokesperson for the Press Club pointed out that journalists faced a prolonged Internet shutdown since August 5, which was a crippling obstacle in performing professional duties.

“As if that was not enough, physical attacks, threats and summons to journalists are being employed by security agencies to intimidate journalists. In fact, the summons to journalists… to police’s counter-insurgency centre (Cargo) in Srinagar has become a routine exercise,” the spokesperson said in a statement.

“The harassment and questioning of journalists in Kashmir on flimsy grounds by the J&K Police for their work is, in fact, a damning verdict on the appalling condition in which media is operating.”

The spokesperson said the restrictions on the Internet and “forcibly seeking undertakings from news organisations for allowing limited Internet access, constant surveillance by police and physical attacks and summons” were all “tools designed and aimed to ensure (that) only (the) government-promoted version is heard outside”.

“However, the meeting today made it clear that journalists are within their rights to report about the happenings from Kashmir impartially and truthfully.”

  • On August 14, the spokesperson said, journalist Irfan Amin Malik was picked up from his residence in Tral and released the next day.

“On August 14, 2019, government forces barged into my house and detained me. I was kept inside the police station for a night. My family reached the media facilitation centre where they along with the media briefed the government about my detention and then finally I was released,” the Press Club quoted Irfan as saying.

  • On September 1, Peerzada Ashiq, who works for The Hindu, was summoned to Kothi Bagh police station where he was questioned and pressured in an attempt to make him reveal the source of a story. “I was asked to reveal my sources who shared official data on detentions with the newspaper,” Ashiq said.
  • On November 30, Bashaarat Masood, of The Indian Express, and Hakeem Irfan, of The Economic Times, were summoned to the counter-insurgency centre where they were grilled, the spokesperson said. “The duo said that they were asked to reveal their sources and how they managed to get documents,” he said.
  • The same month, freelance photojournalist Muzamil Mattoo was beaten up in downtown Srinagar while covering the Khojje Digar prayers.
  • On December 17, two journalists, Azaan Javaid, of the online newspaper ThePrint, and AneesZargar, of NewsClick, were beaten up by the police in full public view in Srinagar while covering a protest. They were allegedly threatened for filing reports against a police officer.
  • On December 23, Masood of The Indian Express and Safwat Zargar of the website were stopped by the police at Handwara while they were on an assignment. “They were taken to the office of the superintendent of police, Handwara. They were questioned about their story and told that by doing the story they were trying to provoke the situation,” the spokesperson said.

Copyright © 2020 The Telegraph. All rights reserved.