Home / India / Congress leader, Health Minister spar on Twitter over Covaxin approval

Congress leader, Health Minister spar on Twitter over Covaxin approval

Bharat Biotech vaccine approval sans due process, says Manish Tewari
Covaxin is yet to undergo its Phase III trials.
Covaxin is yet to undergo its Phase III trials.
Telegraph Picture

Our Bureau, Agencies   |   New Delhi   |   Published 16.01.21, 09:08 PM

Union Health Minister Harsh Vardhan and senior Congress leader Manish Tewari on Saturday had a war of words on Twitter, as the Opposition member raised questions on the emergency use  approval of the Bharat Biotech-made Covaxin. Vardhan on the other hand hit back and said that Tewari was only passionate about spreading rumours.

India’s nationwide vaccination programme commenced on Saturday with thousands getting inoculated with the recently approved Covaxin or the Serum Institute of India-made Covishield vaccine.


In the backdrop of the Covid-19 vaccine roll-out in the country, Tewari raised questions over the emergency use approval given to the indigenously developed vaccine Covaxin and alleged that it was “sans due process”.

“As vaccine roll-out begins, it is all a bit puzzling India has no policy framework for authorising emergency use. Yet, two vaccines have been approved for restricted use in emergency situations,” Tewari tweeted just before Prime Minister Narendra Modi kicked off the programme.

“COVAXIN is another story -- Approvals sans Due Process,” the former Union minister added, tagging a media report which claimed that scientists and doctors are divided on the issue of restricted use approval granted to the Hyderabad-based Bharat Biotech’s Covaxin.

Responding to Tewari's remarks raising questions over approval to Covaxin, Vardhan, in a tweet, quoted English cleric Charles Caleb Colton who said, "So blinded are we by our passions that we suffer more to be damned than to be saved."

“Sh @ManishTewari & @INCIndia are only passionate about spreading distrust & rumours. Open your eyes, sharing photos of eminent Doctors & Govt functionaries getting inoculated,” Vardhan tweeted and posted pictures from the inoculation drive that began earlier in the day.

Hitting back at Vardhan for his jibe, Tewari said, “Dear Dr @drharshvardhan, Concerns that I have articulated are real & not imagined. It is not fear Mongering. Look what is happening in Norway. It may be a different vaccine but do not hide behind vaccine nationalism. ANS QUES Expected better of you Sir.”

Addressing Tewari, in another tweet, the Union health minister said the science behind Covid-19 vaccines is resolute.

“Our scientists have worked at lightning speed to expedite functions that contribute to development of a vaccine but not a single function has been circumvented. Safety above all else has been the guiding principle,” he said.

Tagging Vardhan's tweet, Tewari said, “Well @drharshvardhan since you say so & as you are aware that I have deep personal regard for you I am more than willing to take your word for it. However, why is the medical fraternity so deeply divided over the safety,reliability & efficacy of COVAXIN?”

Tewari also shared a letter on Twitter which was purportedly from the Resident Doctor Association (RDA) of the Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital to the medical superintendent of the hospital in which apprehensions were expressed over the use of Covaxin in the vaccination drive for the resident doctors.

“Is this letter a genuine or a fake? A journalist sent it to me. Just bringing it to your attention. kind of FYA (for your attention),” Tewari tweeted along with the letter.

Earlier this month, senior Congress leaders Anand Sharma, Jairam Ramesh and Shashi Tharoor had also raised concerns over India's drugs regulator's nod to restricted use of Bharat Biotech’s Covid-19 vaccine.

However, there were different voices within the party as its chief spokesperson Randeep Surjewala had lauded scientists and researchers of Bharat Biotech for the indigenous vaccine.

Copyright © 2020 The Telegraph. All rights reserved.