An angry Mani Shankar Aiyar on Tuesday said he was being âhoundedâ by the media, which he said was trying to resurrect the controversy over his âneech aadmiâ remark of 2017, and ordered reporters to go through his article fully instead of creating a false perception based on two lines.
The full article â published first in Rising Kashmir on Monday, headlined âOn Cloud Nine of Nationalismâ â condemned Prime Minister Narendra Modi for indulging in âanti-nationalâ activity, spreading unscientific temper, insulting the armed forces, and suspected his âlyingâ was the outcome of âa compulsive psychological disorderâ.
The Congress quickly distanced itself from Aiyarâs views.
The two lines which Aiyar said are not the crux of the matter are: âThat (Modiâs ouster on May 23) would be a fitting end to the most foul-mouthed Prime Minister this country has seen or is likely to see. Remember how I described him on 7 December 2017?â
In the middle of the Gujarat Assembly election that day, Aiyar had described Modi as âneech kism ka aadmiâ. The Prime Minister promptly interpreted it as a caste slur. The Congress was rattled and suspended Aiyar but many in the party felt Modi managed to garner enough sympathy to add a few more seats to his stock.
The Congress quietly revoked Aiyarâs suspension last year, but he wasnât given any assignment. In his latest article, Aiyar re-ignited the âneechâ debate by stating as the last line: âWas I not prophetic?â
The timing of the new article, when the last election phase is days away, generated much curiosity as the BJP and Modi pounced on his remark with full force.
Congress president Rahul Gandhi anticipated the fallout and tweeted immediately: âIâm pushing for a new language in politics. Letâs fight each other brutally on issues. Letâs fight hard on ideology. But... Letâs not use hatred and violence against each other. Itâs bad for India.â
Congress communications chief Randeep Surjewala disapproved Aiyarâs remark, saying: âHatred, abuse and violence can be Modiâs weapons in politics but no Congressman should stoop that low. Some people do this to remain in news but the Congress does not support this tendency. That is not our tradition. Modi may be blinded by rage and revenge and has been using abusive language. But in the process, he annihilated political decency and the dignity of the high office he holds. Instead of giving sermons on decency, he should explain his own conduct.
âHe called Sonia Gandhi Congress ki widhwa (widow), used expressions like pachaas crore ki girlfriend, patted Himachal BJP chief who gave filthy abuse to Rahul Gandhi, called Manmohan Singh a Pakistani agent. Amit Shah compared Opposition leaders with animals,â Surjewala added.
Asked about the timing of the article, Aiyar told The Telegraph: âRead the article. Donât try to create a false impression using two lines.â
In the article, Aiyar referred to Jawaharlal Nehruâs commitment to the task of creating âscientific temperâ which he said was âan expression that drives sanghis nuts because they like to believe the udan khatolas of mythology were the earliest F-16s to be invented by Hindus, and that Hindu plastic surgery, not a transplant operation, is what led to an elephantâs head surmounting Lord Ganesh. Both these stunningly illiterate claims come from the mouth of none less than the Prime Minister of our country, whose acquaintance with higher education has gone no further than lying about degrees from Delhi and Gujarat universities that he never got and who can obviously not tell a scientific proposition from a dhokla.â
Agreeing that educational qualification wasnât essential for good leadership, he wrote: âBut why lie about oneâs educational qualifications â or lack of them? Unless, of course, such lying is a compulsive psychological disorder.â
He said Modiâs cloud-&-radar logic in the context of the Balakot air strike was âto insult our brave airmen and, above all, the Chief of Air Staffâ; Aiyar also raked up the INS Viraat controversy and argued that Modi should have withdrawn his allegations after four of the senior-most naval officers clarified.
The BJP was quick to make the best of Aiyarâs comeback bid. The glee with which right-wing handles â many with âChowkidarâ prefixed to their names â pounced on Aiyarâs article was testimony to how much he was missed by Modi bhakts in the 17th Lok Sabha elections after he gifted the BJP the âchaiwalaâ comment in 2014.
BJP Rajya Sabha MP GVL Narasimha Rao tweeted: âAbuser-in-chiefâ Aiyar returns to justify 2017 âNeechâ jibe at @narendramodi Ji. Aiyar then apologized & hid behind poor Hindi excuse. Now he says he was prophetic. Congr revoked his suspension last year for filthy outburst. Double speak & arrogance of @INCIndia on display again!â
BJPâs IT in-charge Amit Malviya tweeted: âUpset that Sam Pitroda was getting all the attention, the irrepressible Mani Shankar Aiyar pulls Pitrodaâs foot out of his mouth and puts it in his... Reiterates and justifies his âNeechâ comment for PM!â
Aiyarâs low profile through this election season had spawned various WhatsApp conspiracy theories. Rajya Sabha MP Swapan Dasgupta made a reference to one of them in his tweet: âWelcome back my good friend Mani Shankar Aiyar. Reassured that you werenât there in Balakot. The BJP regretted your absence during the campaign but there is still the final over left.â





