The Telegraph
Thursday, November 23, 2017

SC bins 'unwanted shadow of doubt'

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has dismissed a plea seeking a special probe into bribery allegations linked to the judiciary, saying no FIR can be registered against a judge, let alone the Chief Justice of India, without consulting some of the highest offices in the country.

"There cannot be registration of any FIR against a high court judge or chief justice of the high court or a Supreme Court judge without the consultation of the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India. In case there is an allegation against the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India, the decision has to be taken by the Hon'ble President in accordance with the procedure prescribed in the said decision," the court said.

The bench of Justices R.K. Aggrawal, Arun Misra and A.M. Khanwilkar described as "contemptuous" and "scandalous" two petitions filed by an NGO, the Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms (CJAR), represented by advocate Prashant Bhushan and advocate Kamini Jaiswal, but let them off hoping "good sense" would prevail and they would make "amends".

The petitioners had wanted the court to order a probe into allegations that a retired high court judge had taken a bribe to influence the outcome of a medical college case in the top court. One of the judges who heard the medical college case was the current Chief Justice of India. The petitioners had suggested that an FIR be recorded against the Chief Justice.

The three-judge bench said on Tuesday: "An effort was made to create ripples in this court; serious and unwanted shadow of doubt has been created for no good reason whatsoever by way of filing the petition, which was wholly scandalous...."

 More stories in India

  • Kejriwal, Khattar meet to talk pollution but smog lies over action plan
  • 1500cr fund collected from citizens & trucks lying unused as Delhi chokes in bad air
  • Kerala minister Chandy resigns over land-grab charge against his resort
  • Rajasthan cops say vigilante victim Umar had history of cow-smuggling
  • Delhi may PAY Good Samaritans who take accident victims to hospital
  • Amarnath Shrine Board rapped by NGT for giving pilgrims a bad trip
  • Yogi: Hindutva is development
  • Lack of ambition on health, says Lancet
  • Sluggish growth alert
  • Apocalypse! Cup without Italy, after 60 years
  • Sweet but don't gloat
  • 'Courtesan' slur on Rahul
  • Gauri family losing patience
  • Court slams obstruction for disabled in Delhi
  • Licence must for eateries: Regulator
  • IndiGo case on Delhi terminal
  • Doctors' plea to put off Delhi marathon
  • Coffee tax relief for PC and family 
  • House delay protest
  • Renegade US to owe lives to India, China
  • ICJ run-off vote deadlocked
  • Modi's music to Trump ears
  • RSS labour arm plans anti-govt march
  • Najeeb auto claim scrutiny
  • Rajiv case query after ex-sleuth's disclosure
  • Congress loads Rafale gun
  • Vast health inequalities among states
  • Threat to the system: SC