The Telegraph
Wednesday , September 13 , 2017
 
CIMA Gallary

Interim relief to Ryan Group trustees extended; victim's dad opposes their bail pleas

Mumbai, Sept. 13 (PTI): The Bombay High Court has extended till Thursday the interim protection from arrest granted to the trustees of Ryan International Group, after the father of the seven-year-old boy murdered on the group's Gurgaon school’s campus opposed their anticipatory bail pleas.

The high court directed the boy's father, Barun Thakur, to give the trustees a copy of his intervening application opposing their pre-arrest bail petitions.

Thakur, the father of the Class 2 student Pradyuman, filed an intervening application on Wednesday, opposing the anticipatory bail pleas filed by the group's CEO, Ryan Pinto, and his parents — Augustine Pinto, the founding chairman of the group, and Grace, its managing director.

The Pintos, who sought protection from arrest till they have approached the court concerned in Haryana, were yesterday granted interim protection from arrest till Wednesday.

Thakur's lawyer Sushil Tekriwal on Wednesday informed Justice Ajey Gadkari of his client's intervening application following which the court directed him to give a copy of it to the Pintos' counsel Niteen Pradhan.

”Until and unless you (Thakur) give a copy of the application to the applicants (Pintos), how do you expect them to respond? I will hear the pleas tomorrow. Interim relief to continue till then,” Justice Gadkari said.

When Tekriwal started arguing the matter by mentioning the details of the killing, Justice Gadkari said he cannot hear the matter on merit as his court does not have the territorial jurisdiction.

”This is only a plea for transit bail. I cannot hear the matter on merits,” the judge said.

In the application, Thakur said he is the complainant in the case and the petition of the trustees is “opposed in strongest possible terms and words as the instant case being a rarest of the rare case where a brutal, diabolical, cold blooded, barbarous, demonic, unpardonable, unprovoked, hellish, cruel homicide has taken place on the campus of Ryan International School.”

Pradyuman was found with his throat slit on the morning of September 8, in the toilet of the school.

Police allege that 42-year-old bus conductor Ashok Kumar killed him with a knife after the boy resisted an attempt to sodomise him. Kumar has been arrested. However, the autopsy has ruled out sexual assault.

Thakur alleged in his application that the school's trustees were “vicariously responsible, liable, accountable, answerable for the culpability and guilt for which the bail application should be dismissed in limine (at the threshold).”

Thakur said he was shocked by the trustees' statement that they are not part of the crime as they do not look after the day-to-day working of each school.

If the top management of the school can share in the ”plunder and prosperity”, why should it not face the rule of law because of vicarious liability, the petition said.

He alleged in his petition that it appeared “Pradyuman was meticulously murdered with foolproof planning and conspiracy, otherwise how a conductor sneaked inside with a brand new knife, slitting the throat in a surgically expert manner”.

Thakur said the way the conductor took the child to the hospital and confessed to killing him “immediately” raised doubt which can be cleared during the custodial interrogation of people in the school management.

Thakur also said evidence like blood stains on the floor and clothes were wiped out.

The Pintos, in their pleas, said while the death of the boy was unfortunate, the management cannot be held culpable and that they themselves were victims of ”unfortunate” circumstances.

”The death has caused deep pain and grief not only to the parents and family of the child but also to the trustees, management, staff and students of the school,” they said in their applications, calling the incident the “darkest” hour for the victim's family and the institution.


 More stories in Front Page

  • NSUI makes comeback in DUSU polls, bags posts of president and VP
  • RBI studying case for a cryptocurrency, but wary of private ones like Bitcoin
  • Suu Kyi to skip UN assembly meet
  • Dhaka now has 400,000 Rohingya refugees; UN tells aid agencies to ramp up
  • Is Rahul stupid? His turn
  • Gratuity tax relief ahead
  • Hill baby steps and strike heat
  • Hindu divorce wait cut
  • RSS labels tweets on Gauri 'below the belt'
  • China clarifies river data block
  • Panda rakes up egg attack
  • Quick-fix rush at Birsa home
  • Cyber crime schools & trainers stun cops
  • EC blow to Sharad
  •