The Telegraph
Since 1st March, 1999
Email This Page
ĎNo fellow-maker should comment on a film in printí

Q: Why do you think Black worked'

Black came at a time when the audience was craving for a change. I gave them that change and they embraced my film wholeheartedly. Itís very gratifying, specially since I was repeatedly warned that Black can only be a limited success. ĎCritics and awards will be on your side. But the audience will be cautiousí. Thatís what I was made to believe.

Q: What are the lessons that youíve learnt from the unexpected success of Black'

Why segregate the audience in our minds. I always believe one thing. My films are made because they have to be made. I donít make them for money. You either make films or you make money. Sometimes you get to make some money also. But that canít be the purpose of making a film. Trade papers werenít favourable to Black. They kept saying it wasnít doing well in many areas when, in fact, Black has done well over, including overseas.

Q: What are your future plans for Black'

I donít think getting an Oscar is the ultimate goal for Black. I think the kind of recognition and success that it got goes beyond anything we expected. But, yes, the Oscar keeps recurring in all conversation on Black. I think itís the peopleís way of telling us how much they appreciate the film, and what hopes they have for it. When they say Amitji deserves an Oscar I think they want to tell him he has reached international standards of performance. I agree with that view completely.

Q: So an Oscar for Mr Bachchan and Black'

I feel the West hasnít really acknowledged Indian cinema beyond Satyajit Ray and random parallel filmmakers. But mainstream Indian cinema hasnít been recognised in the West. I wonder where Black fits in! People in India thought it was an off-mainstream film. But it surprised everyone by being accepted by the masses. Now they say Black is ineligible for international recognition because itís inspired by the film The Miracle Worker. That reading of Black is a result of complete misinformation. Both The Miracle Worker and Black are sourced to the play on the life of Helen Keller.

Q: So your film goes back to the play'

Not even that! We just read the play to know about the protagonistís life. From there we constructed our own story and characters. In the play Helen Kellerís life is taken only to a point. Weíve gone much further. Black is a completely original piece of work. I keep reading cynical comments by so-called avant garde filmmakers from our film industry. One of them thinks Black is Ďhammyí. Now what on earth is that' Another one thinks my film is overrated and unrealistic. God bless them and their hardly-seen films. I think such people are trying to get a bit of recognition by trying run my film down.

Q: Your own assessment of Black'

First and foremost, for me itís the most important performance by one of the most brilliant actors of our country.

If nothing else then Black must be acknowledged for Amitabh Bachchanís brilliance and excellence. It wonít return for a long time. He has performed his character with such flamboyance and elan. It isnít over-the-top acting. It isnít hamming. Itís a passionate confirmation of life, no less. And then to have the cynics saying itís no great shakes'
Please, letís have more constructive criticism. Everyone doesnít have to like my film. But if the criticism is done merely to settle scores or to vent your bitterness, then itís not done. No fellow-maker should comment on a film in print.

For me, Black has touched a chord in the hearts of dancers, painters, musiciansÖ artistes and lay persons all over the world. Jealous and unimportant filmmakersí opinions donít matter.

Email This Page