Amartya Sen to awards, loneliness to the love for filmmaking.... Soumitra Chatterjee and Suman Ghosh settled down for a free-wheeling chat with June at the veteran actors Golf Green residence a week before the release of Sumans Dwando (July 24), which features Soumitra as a flamboyant, arrogant doctor.
June: Suman, isnt filmmaking completely different from what you teach or have studied?
Suman: I was always interested in filmmaking and when I was in Delhi School of Economics, I went through this phase of wanting to leave academics and doing films. I met Goutamda (Ghose) one day and told him that I wanted to take up filmmaking as a career. He suggested that I shouldnt give up going to Cornell and filmmaking was something I could take up later. I came away feeling quite irritated and angry. Now I realise that it was perhaps the best advice one could have given me at that time. So even as I pursued my Ph.D, I took courses in filmmaking. Subsequently I made a documentary on Amartya Sen and then I made Podokkhep.... Apparently these are distinct fields but there is a commonality between them that I discover while delving into unanswered questions and quenching my curiosity for both.
June: You say both Amartya Sen and Soumitrada are your mentors...
Suman: I consider myself very lucky to have met such legends. In the US Amartyada is my mentor and here its Soumitrakaku, but theyre very similar people. Theyre roughly the same age, theyre truly international and what I try to imbibe from them is their zest and curiosity to always look forward. At 75, Amartyada still talks about removing world poverty while Soumitrakaku talks about the plays hes going to make. I feel rejuvenated after a conversation with them.
June: Soumitrada is a die-hard romantic. How much of a romantic is Amartya Sen? He cant beat Soumitrada for sure!
Suman: No, hes quite a romantic. We should probably hold a competition for them one day!
June: He cant write poems like Soumitrada so hes already one up!
Soumitra: Well, well, well... these are two different kinds of activities. Maybe he (Amartya) can write something on history which I would never be able to do. I agree with Suman. Its true that weve been able to retain some of the zest for life even in our 70s... although Im forced to battle on with my ailments now, I am a little depressed and sometimes I start thinking about the end. But then, not really.... You cant go on thinking about how you are ending. You have to think that youre going to live and do something to justify your living. This great man Amartya Sen is a big inspiration for everyone. I used to know him when he was a student at Presidency College. I wasnt in that college but he was a classmate of my elder brother. We havent met for ages but somehow were in touch. We have common friends who update us about each other, and its easy to keep track of him because he writes books!
Suman: Amartyada has expressed to me an extreme desire for an adda with Soumitrakaku. I wish to get Amartyada and Soumitrakaku together. Itll be a historical moment!
June: Soumitrada, you did not know Suman when he approached you for Podokkhep, did you?
Soumitra: No, I knew him for quite a few years before that. I had met him on the sets of (Goutam Ghoses) Dekha where he was more of an observer and naturally we bonded because youre so thirsty to meet intelligent, sensitive people. Particularly you (pointing at June) would realise that we hardly come across such people everyday on our sets. So it was a very refreshing encounter with Suman, which continued and one thing that would come up in each of our encounters was his desire to make a film and I encouraged him. Then he came up with the idea of me interviewing Amartya Sen and I said, No, this isnt my cup of tea because I know nothing of economics. Later on when he really thought of a feature film, he sent me his first draft and I sent him whatever little corrections I thought were necessary.
June: How much did you relate to your character in Podokkhep?
Soumitra: As a man ageing and finding it hard to cope with the new reality.
June: Which isnt true in your case...
Soumitra: Yeah... However much you look trim and energetic, when youve crossed 60 you certainly feel that old age is looming large.
June: Are there moments you feel lonely?
Soumitra: What you may develop is a kind of desperation... life is ending, so I must do something. That can prompt you to make a new play, do a new film or write a new poem. But deep down in your heart, you feel depressed. I believe this happens to all mortals.
June: While shooting for Podokkhep I remember telling Suman not to listen to the technicians too much otherwise wed never finish our schedule. Did you overcome that with Dwando?
Suman: I was working in a new environment during my first film. As the director, one of the most important things you need is human resource management... a concept from economics but its actually about balancing your actors, cinematographers and musicians.... A constant state of efficiently managing your people. These were things I was tense about in the first film, but with Dwando I had no inhibitions and I enjoyed every bit of the making. Podokkhep is not a very good film. I would have done so many things differently now. I was surprised when Podokkhep got the National Award because it tells about the state of Bengali cinema but I was overjoyed for Soumitrakaku.
June: Soumitrada, you have a volume of work behind you. What was the first thing that struck you when you got the National Award for Podokkhep?
Soumitra: I had to decide whether I would accept it or not. Had it been two years earlier I would have certainly said Thank you. I dont need it. I had already rejected the special jury award for Dekha once. Tokhon mental obosthatai emon chhilo eshob bhalo lagto na. I had crossed four decades in cinema and been the principal character in 14 of Rays films.
June: Did you feel that some kind of injustice had been done to you?
Soumitra: Yeah... and I was disgusted about the way these selections were made. Somehow I mellowed and matured in the meanwhile, and the moment this announcement was made I started thinking about those who love me. Most Bengalis I know adore me. I felt I would be hurting them if I did not receive this award. Also, what if instead of this film they would later give me an award for one of the commercial films that I go around doing. That would turn out to be much more insulting.
Suman: I remember the day of the award, when he got a standing ovation for five minutes from the luminaries of the film world, the likes of Vidhu Vinod Chopra and Madhur Bhandarkar. It was a proud moment for everyone in Tollygunge.
June: Suman, you received a lot of flak after the National Award. How did you handle all the criticism?
Suman: I dont belong to the so-called Tollygunge film industry but my acceptance has been far greater than the antagonistic comments, so I dont take it seriously.
June: How different is Soumitradas character in Dwando from Podokkhep?
Suman: It is diametrically opposite to the character he had in Podokkhep where he was a lonely old man with a subdued performance. In Dwando hes a flamboyant, arrogant doctor bordering on eccentricity. Since I have the privilege of working with such a great actor, I love to exploit as many facets as I can find in him!
Soumitra: As an actor my artistic principles grew with a conviction that it is not sentimentality that is good for art but genuine emotions that is most essential. You have to demarcate while generating strong emotions.
June: How would you differentiate between Suman the filmmaker and Suman the friend?
Soumitra: As a human being its difficult for me to say since he is almost a member of the family and you dont go about commenting on family members. As a filmmaker hes very promising and thats what matters to me now. Hes been at it from the very beginning, hes developing and since hes not dependent on filmmaking for a living I expect him to make better films.
June: As a friend, Suman, I dont expect you to start a (film) factory like many others have and Ill round it up by saying that Soumitrada, in the next lifetime youre all mine!