Beautiful, but At what cost?
New Delhi, Dec. 26: Children as young as five are routinely being used to quarry stone for the booming British patio and garden landscaping market, one of Britains leading stone importers has warned.
Chris Harrop, a director of Marshalls Plc, said large sections of the gardening industry were turning a blind eye to the use of child labour in the sandstone quarries of Rajasthan to maximise profits.
Only about a third of the 200,000 tonnes of patio stone imported into the UK from India each year was sourced ethically, Harrop said, with the rest often being produced in atrocious conditions.
We want the industry to face facts, he added, and we want consumers to start asking questions. If your New Years resolution is to re-do the patio, then stop and ask yourself where that stone is coming from.
The popularity of gardening makeover programmes has proved a massive boost to the landscaping industry, with stone imports to Britain increasing 10-fold over the past decade, according to customs and excise data.
Up to 100,000 children are employed in Indias quarry industry, which supplies almost three quarters of the imported stone used in British patios and garden features.
Sandstone from Rajasthan is among the most popular, since it most closely mimics the expensive yellow Yorkstone which was traditionally mined in the Pennines but has now been all but exhausted.
Ethically certified stone typically costs 20 per cent more than the cheapest material available, and with competition for business between landscapers intense, price often triumphs over ethics.
Although workers in the quarries earn just 80 paise a day, a single square metre of paving stone fetches about £35 by the time it reaches Britain.
With such huge profit margins on offer, pressure is now growing on the industrys main trade body to enforce a code of ethics.
Denise Ewbank of the British Association of Landscaping Industries (Bali) said there was an implied policy on ethical stone but the issue was becoming increasingly pressing. Using ethically certified stone is not a condition of Bali membership, she said, but this is an issue of intense debate and is already slated for discussion at a board meeting in January.
However, Harrop said the industrys response to his calls to clean up its act had not been encouraging.
Ive visited the quarries in Rajasthan several times, he said, and you can see entire families, from five-year-olds to grandparents, breaking rocks in the searing heat with no health and safety considerations at all.
The trouble is that a large section of this industry doesnt want to think about the fact that it is wrong that a 10-year-old should be digging stone for Britains patios.
Ignorance, said Harrop, is no defence. Unlike the clothing giant Gap, whose Indian suppliers were exposed for using child labour earlier this year, the supply chain for garden stone is transparent.
Ours is a small industry and we can trace our supply chains directly from the quarries of Rajasthan to Mrs Smiths garden.
If consumers knew about the conditions some of the stone was produced in, Im sure they wouldnt buy it.