|
Tagore Tales (Projapoti, Rs 150) contains
one novella and ten of Rabindranath Tagore’s most popular short stories. But the
translations can only sadden those who had welcomed the expiry of copyright on
Tagore’s works. The translation of Nashtanir as “Fouled Nest” would suffice
to illustrate the point. If morning shows the day, then a look at the preface
would be advised. Here the translator, Carolyn B. Brown (who has done the job
with Sharat Kumar Mukhopadhyay), talks about audiences being drawn back
to Tagore by new creations such as Sunil Gangopadhyay’s Ranu o Bhanu, Rituparno
Ghosh’s Chokher Bali, or the television series, Tarpar Rabindranath,
which tried to visualize the life of some of Tagore’s ‘filmed’ heroines 25 years
after their fictional time. One doesn’t quite know who to feel sorrier for — the
“audience”, or Brown herself. The book is a compendium of carelessness and ignorance,
with “Mussalmanir Galpo” being referred to as “Mussalmani Galpo”, Brahmadaitya
(in the context of the Brahmo-elite professor Bamacharan) in “Professor” being
explained as “the Brahmin giant”. The preface also mentions Hemsashi in “Sentence”
as an example of “a recurring figure [in Tagore’s stories], a woman at the window,
often sitting in the dark”. But there is no character by that name in “Sentence”
or “Shasti”.
The Power of N (Rupa, Rs 195) by
Meeta Lall attempts to respond to the problem of our increasingly sedentary
lifestyle and dangerous food habits. Growing affluence has affected our patterns
of eating, both at home and at work. And so Lall suggests several nutrition patterns
for men, women and children, using food guide pyramids and specifying portion
sizes. Sections are devoted to nutrition needs of pregnant women, travelling as
well as desk-bound professionals.
Civil Disobedience Movements in India & India’s
Case for Freedom (Frog, Rs 250) by C.V.H. Rao records the history
of the various satyagraha movements conducted under the guidance of Mahatma
Gandhi and auspices of the Congress and also tries to “appreciate the results
and fruits thereof”. Rao is under no illusion about the movements being run on
the steam of high ideals. His analysis of India’s freedom movement in the context
of international developments, such as the Atlantic Charter, Monroe doctrine and
World War II is useful.
|