George W. Bush was elected 43rd President of the US, but only for a few minutes early on Wednesday. He had victory snatched away from him as Vice-President Al Gore, who had initially conceded defeat, retracted the concession given the slim margin.
Americans were on pins and needles tonight as the choice of a new President to succeed Bill Clinton remained deadlocked. A nationwide vote count revealed that Bush’s “one-vote majority” in the electoral college which chooses the President was the result of a minuscule lead of one-thirtieth of one per cent in the voting in Florida.
Election laws in Florida require that if a poll is won by a majority of one half of one per cent or less, the votes have to be recounted. The recounting may not be completed until tomorrow afternoon, the state’s election supervisor said. The latest figures showed a difference of a few hundred votes.
US television networks, after initially projecting that Bush had won the election, backed off that forecast after the gap narrowed in Florida.
Gore had won 260 votes in the electoral college of 538 members, while Bush had 14 less with returns from two states, Oregon being the other one with seven electors, still awaited. But Florida, with 25 votes, holds the key.
During a long election night of counting the popular votes and tabulating electoral votes, confusion reigned as the crucial electoral votes see-sawed from Republican Bush to Democrat Gore and back again.
The close contest made the outcome in most of the states too close to call. Finally, with results from Florida coming in the wee hours of Wednesday morning, Bush crossed the magic figure of 270 votes, by one.
Gore telephoned Bush, conceded defeat and wished the President-elect well. It was decided that Bush would make an acceptance speech before his supporters in Austin, Texas, where he is Governor, after Gore publicly acknowledged defeat.
But as Gore was driving to his supporters in his hometown of Nashville, Tennessee, aides told Clinton’s vice-president of eight years that all was not lost. They brought to his attention Florida’s requirement of a recount.
It was also revealed that absentee ballots in Florida, estimated variously between 5,000 and 55,000, had not been counted. Bush’s majority in the final tally from the state before the recount was a mere 1,200 votes.
Some Democrat leaders, in any case, had suspected there was something amiss in the counting of votes in Florida, where Bush’s brother Jeb is the Governor.
Gore hastily called off the thanksgiving speech to his supporters and called Bush once again to say that he was retracting because “circumstances have changed”.
“We have now learnt we are down by only about 600 votes out of millions cast and that means an automatic recount. I need to withdraw my concession until the situation is clear,” an aide quoted Gore as telling his opponent.
Bush was stunned. Karen Hughes, the Republican candidate’s communications director, described Gore’s behaviour as “unbelievable”.
A short while later, Don Evans, Republican campaign manager, appeared in front of the Governor’s mansion in Texas and told a crowd of 20,000 awaiting the acceptance speech that he hoped and believed Bush would be the next President. “I’m confident when it is all said and done that we will prevail.”
Around the same time in Nashville, Gore’s campaign manager William Daley told a cheering crowd of Democrats that conceding the presidency to Bush was “premature”. “But this race is simply too close to call and until the results become official, our campaign continues.”
Bush may yet become President after the recount in Florida. But although he has won in almost 30 of America’s 50 states, he will lack a clear popular mandate.
Gore could end up with a higher percentage of popular votes than Bush even if the latter becomes President through a majority in the electoral college. At the time of going to press, Gore, with 49 per cent of the popular votes, was leading by one per cent. He was defeated in his native Tennessee and in Clinton’s home state Arkansas, but he won in the big ones like New York and California.
The turmoil in the race for the White House was not the only bizarre episode on election night. Mel Carnahan, the Governor of Missouri who died in a plane crash last month, was elected to the Senate. His widow will be appointed in his place.